for a Sustainable Future in India
Kids nike mercurial india has long harbored a tradition of ethical vegetarianism, anchored on the dharmic traditions’ commitment to ahimsa (nonviolence). This tradition can perhaps be encapsulated by Prabhupada’s statement, “Indulgence in animal killing for the taste of the tongue is the grossest kind of ignorance, in his translation of Bhagavad Gita 14.16. In particular, for its importance in agriculture and providing milk, the cow has been accorded a special sacred respect in this tradition. Yet, just last year, India attained the dubious distinction of being the largest beef exporter in the world.
In 2009, the UPA government in New Delhi established the Ministry of Food Processing Industries (MFPI), which announced the advent of a “Pink Revolution, noting that India accounted for only 2 percent of the global meat market despite vast potential. Since that time, India’s beef production has already doubled and its share in the beef industry has increased from 8 percent to 25 percent. Such a policy has deleterious implications for a nation with as many faithbased communities and as precarious an ecological situation as India.
The most common argument in favor of the policy is that the government is simply responding to increased demand for meat within a middle class that has undergone a dramatic change in dietary patterns. In 2006, for the first time, the percentage of vegetarians in India slipped to 40 percent. Naturally, demand for meat and dairy products has skyrocketed. Why fault a government for supplying demand? The answer lies in one of the contexts of these dietary shifts. One of the main sources of protein for vegetarian Indians has traditionally been daal, a mixture of lentils. However, due to drought combined with a failure to incentivize cultivation of legumes, India hiked importation of pulses, worsening an already cascading problem of food inflation. One report noted, “Once called the poor man’s diet, daal is now unaffordable, In contrast, MFPI has provided generous tax kids nike mercurial breaks to the beef industry, making it the cheapest source of protein, according to Asia Times. Under increasing pressures to make ends meet, and bearing the brunt of the inflation under the current regime, much of the middle class has replaced daal with beef.
It has also been proposed that the Pink Revolution would provide Muslim and Christian communities greater access to food upon which their religions place no dietary restrictions. Notwithstanding the merits this argument seems to have, India produces more beef than the United States, a country with a selfsufficient beef market with six times the demand of beef as India. Hence, the question of meeting domestic demand through this increase never arises. Conversely, and rather unfortunately, the plan is sure to disturb an interfaith tinderbox since many staunchly vegetarian Hindus perceive Muslims to be responsible for running many of the country’s slaughterhouses.
On the other hand, the government of India has missed out on a significant opportunity to emphasize its notion of “food security” through means that find emphasis in all of the major religions on the subcontinent. The solution is going green, not pink. Sanatana Dharma’s emphasis on caring for the environment is extensive, and is a component of my religious tradition that I hold onto dearly. As one Vedic prayer puts it, “Do not harm the environment; do not harm the water and the flora. Tranquillity be to the atmosphere, to the earth, to the waters, kids nike mercurial to the crops and vegetation, In the Abrahamic faiths, there is also emphasis on keeping guardianship over and protecting God’s creation, while His Holiness the Dalai Lama has noted that in the modern age, there is a growing sense of Universal Responsibility that extends beyond humanhuman contact to how we interact with other forms of life and the environment.
Despite important differences, this abstract, shared concept of ecological stewardship has great promise for tying communities together rather than ripping them apart, as the Pink Revolution appears to be doing. While academic programs such as the Forum for Religion and Ecology at Yale have flourished, such a connection has yielded modest concerted attempts at the ground level where it matters most. Byers has noted through quantitative study, environmental protection is strengthened by local religious and spiritual traditions. We see this principle put into practice, for example, in efforts such as the recent restoration of the Onehunga Bay wetlands in New Zealand by an interfaith coalition. Pandey have noted, these local spiritual traditions of ecology have long existed. Given the importance of faith and tradition to India’s 60 percent rural population, their desperately needed revival poses a wealth of opportunity for interaction across ethnoreligious boundaries.
But what exactly is the way forward? And how are going green and pink intrinsically opposed? Of course, much of Hindu thought suggests killing for meat weighs one down with karmic bondage, while caring for the environment promotes a spiritual kinship with nature. In a nation burdened by mercurial monsoons and lacking in irrigation infrastructure (55 percent of crops are watered by rain), investing 15.5 kL of water in each pound of beef produced only exacerbates the situation. Little attention has been paid to schemes such as the solar canal initiative in the state of Gujarat, which aims to provide irrigation and limit the evaporation of water all while producing renewable energy.
Vandana Shiva, India’s foremost environmental activist who is inspired by her Hindu roots, notes that the future of Indian agriculture lies in small, sustainable farms, not large agribusiness. To this end, slashing tractor subsidies which can provide only environmental damage and encouraging the reintroduction of oxen and cows onto small farms will go a long way to reducing the environmental impact of the country’s farming practices. In fact, this was the norm until very recently, with the NDA government’s National Commission on Cattle making virtually the same proposal in 2001 (which was sadly never acted upon). Other small changes, like promoting the cultivation of pulses, will not only improve soil quality to increase yields, but also provide a traditional, nutritional source of protein.
Thus, the Pink Revolution is at odds with promoting a sustainable future for India. There are not only moral and religious but also several environmental drawbacks from the government’s policies (not all of which could possibly be recounted in one blog post), and they merit serious rethinking. At a time when vegetarianism is on the rise in the West, the Pink Revolution is seriously failing on both an interfaith and environmental level, thereby threatening to bring down kids nike mercurial with it an ethical tradition that has lasted for millennia.
Click here to leave a comment.
HuffPost High School welcomes a lively, thoughtful debate in the comment section.
Post CommentTo reply to a Comment:
Click “Reply” at the bottom of the comment; after being approved your comment will appear directly underneath the comment you replied to.
1. “Smoothies” are a way of making “inconveniently” chewy veggies nike mercurial soccer shoes more palatable without using fuels for cooking just use the blendor instead of the stove, and carry a bottle around when working or traveling. Those enamored of the taste for meat could add very small amounts of it, thus avoid investing much of their rupees in that industry.
2. A kind of “predator snobbery” may underlie nuch of the interest in meateating. The US has over half the military in the world, legendarily always wins every fight, so there is a temptation to “imitate the cowboy” and earn points for what you can kill. I say stand up against the cowardbullies.
3. Beefcattleraising is a major cause of deforestation because trees are mowed or plowed to death to seize ground that can be used to raise feedcrops for the slave meat animals. Read up on Wangari Maathai’s treeplanting movement which prioretizes fruitbearing species which provide nutrition of a higher health priority than meat protein or grain carbohydrate.
Excellent article! I did not know about the fact that India is the biggest beef producer. Its a shame. Also, those who think that eating meat is healthy, don’t realize that its neither healthy nor good for the world/environment in general. The other thing is that you cannot have total peace or harmony in the society when there is any kind of cruelty being practiced. We can’t be loving and be in peace with our own kind (humans) when we practice this mass killing of animals (not just cows) on a daily basis. I think that those who eat meat are more responsible in this than the ones who produce it. If there are no consumers, there won’t be any producers. Finally, no matter what your religion or ethnicity is, Gandhi’s quote applies to all universally: “Be the change you want to see in the world, you want to see peace in the world? (even if its in narrow sense: let’s say for you the world is just you and your family/friends and society around you). you need to practice peace and harmony with all beingshuman or nonhuman. Thanks again for a great article!
“Under increasing pressures to make ends meet, and bearing the brunt of the inflation under the current regime, much of the middle class has replaced daal with beef,
I am an Hindu, and I do not know how to react this statement. NO nike mercurial soccer shoes Hindu in India will buy beef to replace his daal not matter how expensive daal prices may be. So, you are only left with middle class Muslims and Christians which are 1820% of the population but beef is not readily available in every town. So, I don’t know if that statement is correct. Also, what you mean by regime?
I appreciate your inquiry. Allow me to elaborate. It is indeed the case that many “new generation” Indians that were raised in traditionally vegetarian, Hindu households have made this switch, believing to be a natural consequence of “modernity, As I indicate, the number of vegetarians in India has reached an alltime low. Furthermore, you say that beef is not available in every town. This may be the case, especially for small villages. But India now produces 25% of the world’s beef kids nike mercurial.